Home / Cricket / India's New Zealand Tour Is a Test of Depth, Not Just Wins
Cricket India's New Zealand Tour Is a Test of Depth, Not Just Wins
A new column by K R Nayar argues the tour matters most for what it tells India about the kind of team it should build next.

India's tour of New Zealand is being framed as a chance to learn something, not just to pile up wins. In a column for Rediff, K R Nayar argues that the real prize is coming home with a clear idea of what kind of team India should have going forward.
There is a lot going on around the team right now. New players are being tried out, combinations keep changing, and the tour will have a split captaincy. When head coach Gautam Gambhir was resting or unavailable, V V S Laxman stepped into the role, which has fed rumours of split coaches as well. A new selection committee is also in place, with Pragyan Ojha as chairperson and Ramesh Powar as a new member.
The recent West Indies series is a reason for the worry. It was expected to be an easy one, yet India won the ODIs only 2-1 and the T20Is finished 2-2. Nayar says that raises a basic question: India has plenty of good cricketers, but does it have enough genuine match-winners, the kind who deliver when a game is on a knife-edge?
Part of the problem, he suggests, is too much of a good thing. Domestic cricket, India A tours, age-group cricket, state sides and the IPL have all widened the talent pool, and there are now many routes into the national team. Competition pushes players to work harder. But if one bad innings or one expensive spell could cost you your place, Nayar says, a player may start playing not to lose his spot instead of playing to win. A batter might avoid the attacking shot, and a bowler might bowl defensively.
He also questions who really leads the team. In his view, the coach has big influence over selection and tactics, from workload management to batting order, bowling plans and field placements. That risks turning the captain into someone who carries out plans rather than someone who leads. Selectors, he adds, need to know when to change things and when to resist the urge. India's depth lets it try different combinations, but he warns that experimentation has an expiry date.
That is why the New Zealand tour matters. Playing strong opposition away from home tends to expose weak spots, and it should show whether India's bench strength is real. For fans, the takeaway is simple: results will matter, but so will whether the team shows clear roles, confident players and a settled sense of direction.
This article is based on a column by K R Nayar. Read the original piece on Rediff.